Looking to buy a home in Brentwood, NY? You’re not alone. Brentwood is quickly becoming one of Long Island’s most desirable communities for first-time buyers, families, and investors. But not all neighborhoods are the same. In this article, we’ll break down the best neighborhoods to buy a home in Brentwood, based on affordability, community vibe, and convenience.
Whether you’re relocating or upgrading, this guide will help you find the right area that fits your lifestyle and budget.
1. Brentwood Park
If you’re looking for a family-friendly area with spacious properties and access to parks, Brentwood Park is a top choice. It’s located near Ross Memorial Park and the Brentwood State Park, providing plenty of outdoor activities. Homes here are typically single-family ranch-style properties with generous backyards.
✅ Great for: Families with kids, outdoor lovers
💡 Tip: Homes in this area tend to sell quickly, so act fast.
2. North Brentwood
North Brentwood offers a quiet, suburban feel while being close to key amenities and major roadways like I-495 (Long Island Expressway). Many of the homes here are updated colonials and split-level homes, perfect for mid-sized families.
✅ Great for: Commuters, professionals
🚉 Nearby: Brentwood LIRR Station and easy access to NYC
3. Southeast Brentwood
This neighborhood is seeing growth in new development, making it an ideal area for real estate investment or finding a newer home. It’s also close to Brentwood High School and several shopping plazas, which is perfect for families who prioritize convenience.
✅ Great for: Investors, new homeowners
📈 Note: This area is one of the fastest-appreciating zones in Brentwood.
4. West Brentwood
If you want a peaceful, residential atmosphere, West Brentwood is the place. Homes here tend to be well-maintained, with tree-lined streets and access to small community parks. It’s a great place to raise a family or retire in comfort.
✅ Great for: Retirees, long-term homeowners
🏡 Tip: Look for multi-bedroom homes on larger lots.
5. Pine Aire Area
Located on the southern edge of Brentwood, the Pine Aire neighborhood offers affordable pricing and strong rental demand. This area is great for buyers looking for multi-family units or starter homes with investment potential.
✅ Great for: First-time buyers, landlords
💰 Bonus: Lower purchase prices make this area budget-friendly.
Key Things to Consider Before Buying in Brentwood
-
Property Taxes: Like much of Long Island, property taxes can be high. Factor that into your budget.
-
Commute Options: Check proximity to train stations if you work in NYC.
-
School Districts: Brentwood Union Free School District serves most of the area — do your research if school quality is a priority.
Ready to Explore Brentwood’s Neighborhoods?
📍 Arvy Realty is your local expert in Brentwood real estate.
👤 Talk to Hector Villatoro, your trusted neighborhood agent.
👉 Search for homes now or call today for a custom home tour.
📞 Get personalized insights and recommendations to match your lifestyle and budget.