Are you ready to buy your first home and considering Brentwood, NY? You’re not alone. Brentwood, located in Suffolk County on Long Island, is an increasingly popular destination for first-time buyers looking for a balance of affordability, community, and opportunity.
In this first-time homebuyer’s guide to Brentwood, NY real estate, we’ll break down everything you need to know — from market insights to financing tips — so you can confidently make one of the biggest decisions of your life.
Why First-Time Buyers Choose Brentwood, NY
🏡 Affordability
Compared to many neighboring towns like Commack or Bay Shore, Brentwood offers lower median home prices, making it more accessible to buyers entering the market for the first time. In 2025, the average home price in Brentwood hovers around $450,000, providing a great opportunity to invest in homeownership without stretching your budget too far.
🚆 Great Location & Commute Options
Brentwood has easy access to the Long Island Expressway (I-495) and the Sagtikos Parkway, making it convenient for those commuting to other parts of Long Island or even New York City. The Brentwood LIRR Station connects you directly to Manhattan — a big plus for working professionals.
🌳 Family-Friendly Amenities
From public parks and schools to shopping centers and local restaurants, Brentwood has everything you need to feel at home. The town is home to a diverse, welcoming community — ideal for families and young professionals alike.
Step-by-Step: Buying Your First Home in Brentwood NY
1. Get Pre-Approved
Before you start shopping for homes, get pre-approved for a mortgage. This shows sellers you’re serious and gives you a clear idea of your budget.
2. Know Your Must-Haves
Think about what you need versus what you want in a home. Do you need 3 bedrooms? A large backyard? Close to schools? Knowing your priorities will help you stay focused.
3. Work with a Local Expert
Teaming up with a knowledgeable real estate agent — like Hector Villatoro of Arvy Realty — can make the process smoother. Local agents know the neighborhoods, price trends, and can help you navigate your first purchase with confidence.
4. Explore Financing Options
New York State offers programs for first-time buyers, including grants, low-interest loans, and down payment assistance. Your agent or lender can help you find the right program for your situation.
5. Schedule Home Tours
Visit homes in person to get a feel for the neighborhood. Brentwood offers single-family homes, split-level houses, and ranch-style properties — each with its own charm.
Real Estate Tips for First-Time Buyers in Brentwood
-
Stick to Your Budget: It’s easy to get excited, but make sure to account for property taxes, insurance, and maintenance.
-
Consider Future Growth: Brentwood continues to develop with new amenities, which can mean rising home values.
-
Don’t Skip the Inspection: A home inspection protects your investment and may save you from costly surprises.
Find Your First Home with Arvy Realty 🏠
Ready to take the next step? At Arvy Realty, owned by Hector Villatoro, we specialize in helping first-time buyers like you find the perfect home in Brentwood and beyond.
👉 Start your home search here
📞 Call us today for a free consultation and personalized tour of Brentwood NY homes!